Key issue 2: Religious changes 1547-1558

  • Created by: alhl
  • Created on: 07-06-16 15:18

1. Religious reform 1547-1553

England 1547

  • Death of Henry VIII (Catholic with teh monarch at the head of the church)   --> Edward VI is protestant
  • Edward Seymour (Somerset) dominates the regency council after the death of Henry VIII 
  • Changes to the ordinary English people's values and attitudes (they have previously been raised on Catholic values)

                       - Catholic churches are visually appealing + traditional

                       - protestant emphasis on preaching

  • Have to convince the high ranking members of the church (Bishops) 

                       - Clergy, Somerset is protestant (moderate)

1 of 19

2. To what extent did England become protestant un

- Church of England was still Catholic without the pope as the head of the church (still support for traditional practices and changes resulted in unrest)

- Difficult to remove traditional catholic practices                                                                                                        ~Would have to win over the heart and minds of the English people                                                                                                                ~ Protestantism was less visually appealing (harder to convince)

Religous reform under Somerset proceeded slowly and cautiously 

  • Old traditional practices were attacked and destroyed 
  • Bishops were divided in their change
  • Lower clergy opposed the change
  • No fully reformed Church put in place

1547 Protestant reform

  • Royal visitation (examined the state of the clergy and practices of the church)
  • Book of Homilies placed in every church
  • All clergy ordered to conduct their services in English 
  • Iconoclasm, the removal of images and statues
2 of 19

3. Chantries and Treasons Act 1547

Chantries Act 1547

  • Economic reasons, used to raise money to fund the war against Scotland
  • Religious reasons, to remove/attack superstition by removing them

Treasons Act

  • Parliament repealed the Treason Act 
  • Free to discuss more radical reform 
  • Released more radical views, unrest and iconoclastic attacks

-Government was now in a stronger position to bring in more protestant measures due to

  • The success of the campaign against Scotland
  • Changes through the Act of uniformity 
  • It would satisfy the moderate reformers
3 of 19

Religious reforms

  • Sacraments consisted of just communion, baptism, confirmation, marriage and burial 
  • Clergy allowed to marry 
  • masses for the souls of the dead not approved
  • masses to be in the vernacular (English)

Success of Gov. attempts to introduce moderate protestantism 

  • Difficult task as many of the clergy did not know the mass, prayers + Bible very well 
  • However showed their willingness to improbve the Church

Religious changes under Nortumberland

  • New ordinal (Jan 1550) universal procedure for the ordination of priests
  • > led to the battle between Ridley and Cranmer + Hooper declined the part of Bishop of Gloucester
  • Changes had already been made + attack on Catholics
  • > july 1547: Royal injunctions ordered the removal of religious images
  • >february 1548: All images to be removed
  • >december 1549: Proclaimation orders the destruction of the remainder of images
4 of 19

Protestant reforms in 1550

- Conservative Bishops were deprived of their sees

- Gave the reformists a majority among the bishops 

- When parliament met in January 1552 the government was able to embark on a large-scale programme of protestant reform

- A new Treason Act was introduced, made it an offence to question the Royal supremacy or any beliefs of the Church

- Followed by a Second Act of Uniformity 

Reform was widespread across England with the mass population in support of the new religion

- Destroying of religious images, made the imposing of protestantism even clearer to the laity

- Second Book of Common Prayer, removed doubts about the changes from the First Book of Common Prayer, any other form of book was illegal

5 of 19

Edward's Death + was England protestant? (argument

- There were steady but slow moves towards protestantism throughout Edward's reign, but major ones were only brought in during the last few years of his reign 

  • Second Prayer Book 
  • Act of Uniformity 
  • Forty-Two articles
  • Little time to impact + Forty-Two articles never became law due to Edward's death

- Changed in comparison with 1547

  • Influence of the two protectors 
  • influence of the protestant bishops
  • overseas theologists e.g Martin Luther

- Officially a protestant nation

  • Churches had been changed
  • Altars replaced with communion tables
  • New service used 

Hard to judge the extent to which the ordinary people of England welcomed protestantism, people did not welcome or oppose the changes (ignores Prayer book rebellion + London and East Anglia welcomed the changesFast restoration of catholicism meant protestant changes weren't that strong.

6 of 19

Religious change: An overview

Edward  - Changing the prayer book to the English from Latin (Vernacular)                                                                  - Catholic mass is now illegal 

Mary   - Heresy laws (thought she was doing right by religion)                                                                      -               - Married Phillip (very catholic) helped bring back catholicism 

7 of 19

Political crisis?

Political crisis? (yes)

  • Somerset was only able to seize power through manipulating Henry's will
  • The nature of the government changed under Somerset so that it was run through his household 
  • The rebellions of 1549 resulted in the political elite abandoning their support of the government
  • Somerset's overthrow in the autumn of 1549 created instability 
  • The struggle for power between Northumberland + Catholic faction
  • Lady Jane Grey affair resulted in the raising of armed forces
  • Wyatt came close to toppling Mary

Political crisis (no)

  • The legitimate monarch always triumphed
  • the crown passed peacefully from Henry to Edward and from Mary to Elizabeth
  • Even during factional struggles government continued 
  • Henry VIII's will upheld
  • Somerset's attempted coup was short lived
  • The ruling elite supported the rightful monarch: Even in 1553 they supported Mary once Northumberland left London
  • Iconoclasm - Destruction of Catholic art (statues and stained glass windows)
8 of 19

Religious reform 1553-1558 (Mary)


  •  Fights with Edward in order to continue practicing Catholicism
  • Mother = Catherine of Aragon (Spanish+devout catholic)

Proclamation on religion 16 Aug 1553

  • Does not say she is forcing everyone to be catholic
  • Waiting for Parliament before forcing any changes
  • makes her seem tolerant + builds up support (prevents conflict + able to keep support)
  • Works written in English are not allowed (people may come up with their own ideas)
  • 16th Aug, just ascended to the throne (peaceful)

Mary not proceeding cautiously

  • Devout Catholic, though Edward's early death was a sign from God to restore catholicism 
  • Stubborn (abandoned Royal supremacy)
  • Carries on having catholic mass even after Edward deems it illegal 
  • > Oxford Chalices reappeared + August 23rd altar and cross was set up with mass being said
9 of 19

Mary's religious views + support

Unsure whether support was due to her religion or the fact that she was the legitimate heir

  • Failure to see that many had profitted from the disolution of the monastries ( unable to get monastries back + rebuild churches)
  • Thought that God had let Edward die as a sign to change the religio in England 
10 of 19

Mary's religious goals

- Undo the changes made since 1529

  • Restore Papal authority 
  • Restore traditional Catholic practices and belief in transubstantiation
  • Re-establish religious houses that had been dissolved 
  • End clerical marriage and restore the status of priests
  • Secure a long term future for catholicism (by marrying and having children)
  • Persecute those who did not agree with her views


  • People (governing elite) do not like the power the Pope has over religion + Queen
  • To provide an heir Mary would have to marry (foreign= power over court + wars)
  • There were protestants that may not believe in Catholic practices
  • Persecuting protestants may lessen her support as matyrs are made

Reservations of advisors

  • Gardiner was uncertain about restoring Papal supremacy
  • Concerns about trying to restore former monastic property
  • Concerns Mary would proceed too quickly + provoke unrest (might threaten her position as queen)
11 of 19

How popular were Mary's religious policies? Pt.1

Popularity at her Accession

  • Mary was still catholic and hadn't completely changed with Edward's laws 
  • Oct 1553, Parliament met but refused to repeal the Act of Supremacy (suggests anti-papal feeling)
  • > passed Act of Repeal which undid the changes made under Edward, restored the religious situation of 1547 under the Act of Six Articles
  • Mary used the Royal prerogative to suspend the Second Act of Uniformity + restored mass 

Signs of faction

- Wyatt's rebellion

  • Took place before Mary had changed anything significant
  • Reaction to the fears of the spanish marriage rather than religious changes 

Protestant reaction to catholicism 

  • Early month of 1554 some protestants began to leave England for Germany or Switzerland
  • > mostly gentry, clergy + more wealthy (around 800) + not an option for the less well off
12 of 19

How popular were Mary's religious policies? Pt.2

Royal injunctions spring 1554

  • Restoration of some traditional catholic practices (e.g Holy days, processions, ceremonies + also led to the deprivation of large numbers of married clergy)
  • Protestant bishops were removed from their offices
  • April 1554, parliament rejected the reintroduction of heresy laws, did not agree until promises were made that former monastic lands would not be restored to the church
  • Parliament refused some of the religious changes (factional struggle between Pagett and Gardiner)
  • Parliaments concern for the sanctity of property rather than opposition to the religious changes

Second Act of Repeal Nov 1554

  • Repealed all religious legislation approved since 1529
  • Mary forced to compromise with the land owners
    • Act protected the property rights of those who had bought church land since 1536
    • Mary forced to recognise parliaments authority in religious matters
    • prevents full-scale catholic restoration

- October 1555, Bishops Ridley and Latimer were burnt at Oxford

13 of 19

How popular were Mary's religious policies? Pt.3

Burning of Cranmer 

  • March 1556
  • Seen as necessary to Mary as he ended her parents marriage + made her illigitimate + supported LJG
  • Made a matyr for the protestant faith

Death of Gardiner

  • November 1555
  • Removed a restraining influence on Mary
  • Initially encouraged the persecution of protestants (to scare extremists) , soon aware of the failure
  • Followed by an increase in persections

- 274 Executions in the last three years of Mary's reign (believed it was her duty to remove heresy)

14 of 19



  • Large numbers in attendance (in London + other towns)
  • Welcomed as a chance to make money
  • Earlier in the day (had to move) due to the overwhelming number of people + disruptions
  • Most took place in the south-east
    • greater concentratio of protestants
    • closer to London


  • Some argue that it did much to damage Mary's popularity
  • Some argue it did little to harm or help the catholic cause
15 of 19

Impact of burnings

Heresy laws were reintroduced in 1554 and burnings are continued from february 1555

John Rogers

  • A Biblical translator who was burnt at the stake for translating the Bible into English
    • multiple copies, results in more people reading it and interpreting it for themselves (solascriptura)
    • vernacular, language of the country
    • against catholic values, was a protestant

John Foxe

  • Suggests there was opposition to the Marian burnings + the burnings turned England protestant 
    • suggests the burnings converted those imprisoned by the dedication (research has challenged this view)
16 of 19

Mary's death + was England catholic?


  • Mary did not reign long enough for catholicism to hold in the public (new generation born into protestantism as their main religion)
  • Changes made by Henry + Edward were not and could not be completely undone, resulted in long-term rejection of catholic churches
  • New publications - catholic New Testament + new Book of Homilies (plan for catholic revival) > However, little time to make any impact on the people 
  • Government tried to prevent the publication of protestant literature, not successful suggested books from Edward's reign allowed for protestants underground


  • Cardinal Pole, regular visitations to check on clerical behaviour 
  • New publications - catholic New Testament + new Book of Homilies
  • Money was donated to help restore catholic churches destroyed in Edward's reign
  • Took Elizabeth some time to restore protestantism and the Church of England, shows success in the Marian regime
17 of 19

The religious pendulum pt.1

1547 Catholic Doctrineend of Henry VIII's reign

  • 1547, Removal of catholicism 
    • iconiclasm (removal of icons) + Act of supremacy 

1548 Unofficial protestantism

  • first Book of Common Prayer 

1549 Moves to protestanism

  • first Act of Uniformity

1552 Fully protestant second prayer book

  • 42 Articles, second Book of Common Prayer + second Act of Uniformity

1553 Death of Edward VIII

  • legally protestant, Act of Repeal
18 of 19

The religious pendulum pt.2

1553 Removal of protestantism 

  • arrest of Cranmer, Latimer, Hooper + Kidley

1554 Restoration of catholic doctrine + Papal supremacy

  • royal injuctions, Heresy laws passed + Cardinal Pole returns to England 
  • second Act of Repeal 

- 1555 Persecution 

  • John Rogers becomes first protestant matyr
  • Latimer + Ridley burned for heresy

1556 Reformed Oath

  • Cranmer burned (showed alligence to the Pope)

- 1558 Death of Mary Tudor (catholic doctrine)

  • Elizabeth returns the Church of England
19 of 19


No comments have yet been made

Similar History resources:

See all History resources »See all British monarchy - Tudors and Stuarts resources »